
Thanks to Helen for the post I quote below.
On his blog Jesus Creed Scot McKnight has been asking pastors what advice they’d give a new pastor knowing what they know now.
In today’s post Scot asks my friend Rose Madrid-Swetman that question. Here’s part of Rose’s response
I would focus on “growing a church big rather than growing a big church.” When I first began as a pastor, I was taught to focus on buildings, budgets, and butts in seats. Those three words were, and in many cases still are, the measure for success. Today we (I don’t lead in a vacuum) focus on the other words: conversations, connections, and collaborations.
When one moves down the alphabet from buildings, budgets, and butts to conversations, connections, and collaborations, one counts success differently. Here are a couple of examples: We count how many people we have served rather than how many people attend our Sunday morning gathering (yes, we have one). We count how many people we are developing, encouraging, and partnering with to be practitioners, who are leading personal, local, and global expressions of God’s goodness and justice.
Growing a church big is a great adventure.
Who wouldn’t get excited about this? Here is a real option for people who have been longing for a new way to evaluate ministry effectiveness
- I notice the old evaluators were external, superficial, self-centered, easily measurable, done in isolation, and have no lasting value.
- The new ones are all relational, focused toward others, hard to measure, done through partnerships, and have deep significance for this life and all eternity.
This is great. Help me to unwrap it.






Thanks Glen! I thought Rose’s answer was awesome.
Relational sounds good to me…
By: Helen on May 14, 2008
at 9:19 pm
Helen ~ She is an insightful woman. Thanks for the post.
By: Glenn on May 15, 2008
at 12:45 am
just becareful not to create a new dead thing that sounds good because in a few years you’ll find the deadness in them as well.
we once thought numbers were good because we wanted to help save as many as could before the curtin clothes- honorable intentions since we read that Jesus longed for NONE to perish…
but it became a man made ministry that seemed right to us…….and soon became a dead thing with corruption-
and we can now look back, reflect and see how self centered it really all is.
So be careful not to make conversations, connections and collaborations the new movement; ministry…….
make certain that those connections are real- and not just a power point presentation that you are following; and that in the conversations- you are really listening and not just being a good guy sitting with someone while they are chatting…..
and collaborate with that or those which really belong- because corruption flurishes in collaborations as far as I can see.
You have good thoughts- so does Rose….
I just find myself treading very carefully these days- least I make the same mistakes but call it a better name.
By: jane on May 17, 2008
at 8:36 am
edit-
before the curtain closed…….ie; time ends- no more can get into heaven.
By: jane on May 17, 2008
at 8:37 am
oh, and that is just my opinion; I am not judging what you are doing- just sharing my thoughts- take em or leave them.
By: jane on May 17, 2008
at 8:38 am
Jane ~
Those are all thoughtful and valid warnings. I like these “3 c’s” because they stand in stark contrast to the “3 b’s” and because it provides something of an answer for people who have been trying to figure out how to be the church and are wondering it if they are on target at all. Of course, like anything, it could be over emphasized or abused.
By: Glenn on May 17, 2008
at 11:23 am